Sometimes celebs' over-the-top red carpet makeup just looks so dramatic and cool, and other times we totally prefer their toned-down, more natural makeup looks. Stars like Selena Gomez, Ariana Grande, Taylor Swift, and Bella Thorne constantly have fun with their makeup and switch their styles up between the two. When they're rocking smokey eye makeup, vibrant lipstick, or nude gloss, we can't pick a look we like most!
Click through the gallery to see what your fave stars look like with both natural and dramatic makeup styles. Then vote in each poll to tell us which look you think looks best.