Vanessa vs. Ashley: Who Looks Better?

ashoct21.jpg

vanessaoct21.jpg

Both Ashley and Vanessa looked gorge when they stepped out in New York City in these trendy outfits. Who do you think looks better? Ash in her light blue fringe dress, or V in her pretty skirt outfit? Comment on your fave look!

114 Comments

They both rock but I'm going to have to say....
Vanessa!

Katy Jonas on October 21, 2008 6:37 PM

both of their outfits are cutee but i agree...i'm gonna have to say V.

Hey wats up I think Vanessa looks a lot better no offense to Ashley but I think Vanessa matches and I am all about matching outfits.

ashley would look best if she still had blonde hair. but sience she didnt i have to stay ash!

Both of them rock in their own way. Don't get me wrong, I like Ash's fringe dress. And both of them are wearing simple outfits. But something about V's style is a little better than Ash.

i love both but v wins

No one take any offence to this but, don't get me wrong i LOVE both outfits(and them), but V might have beat Ash out if ash was still a blone then she'd win hands down!

ashely rocks
vannesa sucks loser loser loser you wish you where her just forget about it v because you are not baby v any more because it goes ash baby. vannesa you suck. miley rocks and selena. nick and selena are so hucking up.

^^ Vanessa rocks rocks rocks! She's not a loser. her and ash rock. Vanessa rocks so shut up!

both of them rock! ash is my idol! but i think v's style is betta there

I think that V's style looks a lot cuter. The black oots don't go with Ash's blue fringe dress.

gilliana330 on October 21, 2008 10:54 PM

i think Vanessa looks better, but Ash still looks great!

i like Vanessa better, but Ash still looks great!

well, im not big on either of them, but i do have to say ashley looks great with her dark hair. i like ash better...

i think vanessa looks betta because the black skirt looks amazing with the blue top but i love ashleys hair so im gonna have to say vanessa but i still love ash

Hiya!I love both of them but Vannessa looks more prettier.

wow they both looked super hott, but i think vanessa looked better. i think the dress showed off her body, her legs especially, and her tan. she just looked super hott.

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

They're both great HSM stars
although in these pics, I'd like Ashley's get up more. She looks sophisticated with that look and for me, she looks beautiful regardless of the hair color ^_^
I also didn't like vanessa's legs in this pic...
ashley is simple yet elegant!

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

vanessa looks more gorgeous!!

ashleyannjonas on October 22, 2008 3:12 PM

me personally i luv them both
i think they are two pretty women
no homo
=)

I love them both! But I like Ashley's outfit more.

Tatiana90434 on October 22, 2008 4:19 PM

Ashley cuz the puppy atracted MY eye i

i think ashley's is cuter but i love them both

I like Ash's better but she has a cute little dog that also wins

Ashley ann Jonas girls are lesbians guys are homos. Im surprised Zac is dating V I thought he was homosexual. Ashley looks better though...sorry v

OMG that is so hard to choose from but I'm going to have to say Vanessa.

VANESSA WINS! SHE DOES NOT SUCK STUPIDS! SHUT UP!!!

I say Vanessa because it looks more better

as looks better

I have to say Vanessa, Ashleys is to much

VANESSA'S LOOKS BETTER!!

ZAC IS NOT A HOMO!!!!! eventhough i dont like him i gotta stand up for him.... Ash's pup made her outfit go together but V's outfit matches more. i think they both look FABULUS!! (that is not a typo) P.S. ZAC IS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONOT A HOMOSEXUAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I like Ashleys better. And.... style is not everything. This is what I am wearing right now.
Purple skinny jeans, a yellow long sleeves shirt with a cat tank top over it, pink frog socks, and leopard pumps. My hair is in a low ponytail. Go Ashley and Miley. I love Ash.:D

vanesssa

miss-tisdale on October 24, 2008 5:25 AM

ashley looks so cool i love her more than vanessa

dont understand me wronge vanessa lovers
but i guess ashley is sooo much talented
and fashionable than vanessa
in talent carer because ashley sound better better
and she have been amazing in suite life of
zack and cody
and in fashion cuz vanessa looks classic
and ashley can change from rock to soft
from hot to cute
she is amazing

OF COURSE ASHLEY WINS

ash rox

Sry ash but im gona say Vanessa

sry ash but im gona say Vanessa

hay, i think that vanessa look better than ashley. But i love them both

Maria Jonas (married to nick,btw) on October 24, 2008 1:36 PM

ash looks SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much cuter with brown hair! brown hair is ALWAYS prettier than blonde thats a known fact.

Ashley totally!
~Tess

Both look super cute, but V totally rocks it with the dark jewerly!

I think V looks better !

Well i like Ashley better but the outfits i gotta say vannesa.What happen to ashleys beutiful blond hair!

I do think Vanessa is more taleneted and fashionable than Ash but there both great!

Vanessa looks so much better
I dont like neither of them because of their past records but Vanessa really wins this one!!

I don't really like eithe of them because of their pastrecords but I would have to say that Vanessa realy bets Ashley in this one

i have to Vanessa!!! she looks better. i love her i'm going to see hsm3 in theaters today!!!!!i think Vanessa is the best!!!

I think that they both look good in their own way. They are both rockin different styles and I like them both. Im not here to badmouth anybody!

hey katie you bictch!!!vanessa rocks,im so sorry vannessa that she called you that stuff.katie,you suck,your a loser,and your a fuckking baby!!!!

I agree with Lynn they both have really awesome styles and I think that if they love what they are wearing we should not care...besides their style does not always define who that person is.

katies soon to be worst enemy you are mean! Maybe you like her, but dont get defensive over someone you dont know. You dont know Katie of V so why are you getting all mad. Guys please stop fighting we dont know each other we dont have a reason to fight. I like Ashley and Vanessa both. Nessa is a really cool person.

michelle G#$^%* on October 26, 2008 6:26 PM

hey i think vanessa looks alittle better thatn ash in the picture. i also like how they did vannessas hair. LOVE IT !!!
:-D

I have to agree ash would look better if she still had blonde hair but anyway they both look cute but i have to say v

im a big fan for both
but ashley looks cute and natural
but what vanessa wears something bigger than her
but vanessa u still rock

love u ashley

vhudgensbiggestfan on October 28, 2008 8:21 PM

UMM NOT EVEN A QUESTION VANESSA!!!!!!!
i hate ashley shes so ugly with blonde hair or not VANESSA IS MY IDOL I LOVE HER SO MUCH MORE THEN ANY1/ANYTHING
ANYTHING VANESSA WARES DOES SAYS IS AMAZING
I LOVE BABY V SHE IS MY LIFE
ND SHE IS THE MOST GORGEOUS GIRL EVER!!
DONT EVER COMPARE VANESSA TO ASHLEY ASHLEY SUCKS VANESSA IS AMAZINGG
VANESSA HAS MORE FANS THEN ASHLEY EVER WILL!!!!

i think that vanessa shows off i mean im iraqi i know if a gurl shows off or not i think that ashley is perfect with zac even though zac is the cheeziest and dumbest guy ever and ithink he should get a life i say ashley all the way

I lov both outfits but theres somthing about vs that just stands out! She just looks so stunning.

vanessa looks so cute. and i have been told i look like her.(:

Hello i think that vanessa looks way better than ashley

~*crazi_grl*~ on October 31, 2008 2:42 PM

vanessa definetely!!! ashley's doesn't really look good.
i mean with the boots. ewww!! i love her dog though!!!

Vanessa! Nothing against Ashley I love them and are both gorgeous, but V is prettier than Ash.

I love Vanessa's skirt outfit its so cute!Her chunky necklace really finishes the outfit where as Ashley's jacket and boots don't match as well with the light blue dress! Still love them both! HSM3 was great!

vanessa is a slut and gay and ashley is way better looking then baby v or vanessa dont care whatever like it matters.

ps: you rock ashley cant wait to see your movie they came from upstairs!!!!

ash looks better cuz i hate v stuff & all u guys can hlp me out by sending me a comment at www.soad head.com im' 16 too or give me a tag let plese those are my comment bye.

i mean't that is my comment.

They both look really great,but i'm gonna have to say vanessa looks better. i mean look at v's outfit it is soooooooooooooooooo!!! cute! i love the blue shirt with that sassy black skirt! Ashley on the other hand looks great to but she should just stick with th blonde hair! brown just does not work for her, but her dress was kind of cool. Goooooooo! vanessa!

I think vanessa look's way better than ashley, I mean look at V's outfit it is soooooooo! cute with that sassy black skirt. but on the other hand ashley should just stick with blonde brown does not work for her! goooooo! vanessa!

vanessa is not a slut and she is not gay!!!! vanessa rocks like i said before!!!!

I think that Vanessa is rockin' her classy look. I love the blue top she is wearing, it makes her look sophisticated... yet young.

i love v's outfit ity rocks but ashley's outfit is also cute,i have to say vanessa

They both look stylin but i'm going to say V's outfit
has a bit more "something" then Ashley's.

vanessa looks better i like her better

i like better!much more trendy!

I think Vanessa looks better.

I think that vanessa because her outfit is great

asley's dress was simple while vanessa is kind of over dress no offence but vanessa look great

i think ashley cutier

vanessa looks more cutier


but ashley is still pretter

Jessie Bear on November 4, 2008 7:30 PM

I totally like Ashley better (no offence V) but I definetly have to say that V looks a LOT better!

Jessie Bear on November 4, 2008 7:30 PM

I totally like Ashley better (no offence V) but I definetly have to say that V looks a LOT better!

Ashley is more beautiful than vanessa,she sings better vanessa looks and sounds stupid (no offence)sorry but i think vanessa it`s complitly out of fashion! I hope onwe daay you will be with Zack It`s just my opinion

I'm gonna say V on this one, although they are both pretty! No offense Ashley cuz you are beautiful too!!!!!

ashley sucks v rules go baby V

ash is so ugly but v is so beautiful

nrihgbxt mzwsiybq cdmvzxykj auplb ercyibad waumv wurvcdb

i love Vanessa she owns Ashley!!!!Vanessa is sooo pretty!i love her she is my rolemodel!i hate the people that call her "names" i love her because she is an amazing rolemodel people think she is something because of the "picture" but NOBODY is perfect EVERYBODY makes mistakes!she learned from her mistakes because she never did it again!she also proves that EVERYBODY makes mistakes and she continued to be an awesome rolemodel i love her she is AMAZING!!!!

_'i think vanessa looks the best!!!! she's d most gorgeous persOn i kNow.....LOVE her sOOoo mUch!!!
sHe's #1 fOr mE....!!!!!!!!!

Both look really nice, but I'd have to say Vanessa. No offeence to Ashley, but Vanessa's style looks more cool and chic. Equivalent to hot! hahahs. So my conclusion is: Vanessa. xD .

Vanessa looks best! :-)

jpyc rakzmq nskdp

vfsw cqvag dgxpiql wscy

VANESSA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Cheta Mbajekwe on December 7, 2008 6:35 PM

they both luk gorgeous but as u all hav 2 accept d fact that Ash simply RULES!!...............................................

dnjfexrg nire xveduf ptlrca nome emwvyj idtepr

dnjfexrg nire xveduf ptlrca nome emwvyj idtepr

Vanessa dark blue shirt and black everything else are too much. Ashley def knows what she's doing wearing a light blue dress under her dark sweater.

Vanessa's dark blue shirt and black everything else are too much. Ashley def knows what she's doing wearing a light blue dress under her dark sweater.

Vanessa's dark blue shirt and black everything else are too much. Ashley def knows what she's doing wearing a light blue dress under her dark sweater.

Vanessa's dark blue shirt and black everything else are too much. Ashley def knows what she's doing wearing a light blue dress under her dark sweater.

I'm from Brasil ,but i have say :

VANESSA HUDGENS IS SOO BETTER !

Vanessa Anne Hudgens on December 27, 2008 1:36 PM

Hey Guyz
Ashley Is Very Pretty And Thank You To The People Who Said I Was Pretty Thank You I Love Youxx
But Why Am I A Loser:(
But Me And Ash Give Eachother Ideas To Look Better So
I Love You Guyz
Peace Out
Vanessa♥

Vanessa and Ashley know how to rock their outfits but for this i am gonna have to say that i like Ashley's dress the most it looks great on her.

Ashley 100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 %

I like vanessa's dress.
Ashley u suck my pea nuts

Vanessalover (kayce) on February 18, 2009 12:51 AM

for me.... vanessa is more beautiful than ashley... but this is only m opinion...

i like her soo much..
her voice
face............

and shes a filipina...

and im a filipina too.

i like her not only because shes a filipina..

for me she is soooo beautiful....

ashley is kinda cute too..

but i dont like her face......

let say that shes beautiful...

but for you..

not me............

go baby V..........

im always here for you..always supporting you...
hope you can come here in philippines..
love yah!

Vanessalover (kayce) on February 18, 2009 12:52 AM

for me.... vanessa is more beautiful than ashley... but this is only m opinion...

i like her soo much..
her voice
face............

and shes a filipina...

and im a filipina too.

i like her not only because shes a filipina..

for me she is soooo beautiful....

ashley is kinda cute too..

but i dont like her face......

let say that shes beautiful...

but for you..

not me............

go baby V..........

im always here for you..always supporting you...
hope you can come here in philippines..
love yah!

Vanessalover (kayce) on February 18, 2009 12:54 AM

for me.... vanessa is more beautiful than ashley... but this is only m opinion...

i like her soo much..
her voice
face............

and shes a filipina...

and im a filipina too.

i like her not only because shes a filipina..

for me she is soooo beautiful....

ashley is kinda cute too..

but i dont like her face......

let say that shes beautiful...

but for you..

not me............

go baby V..........

im always here for you..always supporting you...
hope you can come here in philippines..
love yah!

Vanessalover (kayce) on February 18, 2009 12:55 AM

for me.... vanessa is more beautiful than ashley... but this is only m opinion...

i like her soo much..
her voice
face............

and shes a filipina...

and im a filipina too.

i like her not only because shes a filipina..

for me she is soooo beautiful....

ashley is kinda cute too..

but i dont like her face......

let say that shes beautiful...

but for you..

not me............

go baby V..........

im always here for you..always supporting you...
hope you can come here in philippines..
love yah!

Vanessalover (kayce) on February 18, 2009 1:02 AM


for me.... vanessa is more beautiful than ashley... but this is only m opinion...

i like her soo much..
her voice
face............

and shes a filipina...

and im a filipina too.

i like her not only because shes a filipina..

for me she is soooo beautiful....

ashley is kinda cute too..

but i dont like her face......

let say that shes beautiful...

but for you..

not me............

go baby V..........

im always here for you..always supporting you...
hope you can come here in philippines..
love yah!

Vanessalover (kayce) on February 18, 2009 1:04 AM


for me.... vanessa is more beautiful than ashley... but this is only m opinion...

i like her soo much..
her voice
face............

and shes a filipina...

and im a filipina too.

i like her not only because shes a filipina..

for me she is soooo beautiful....

ashley is kinda cute too..

but i dont like her face......

let say that shes beautiful...

but for you..

not me............

go baby V..........

im always here for you..always supporting you...
hope you can come here in philippines..
love yah!

WIN $500 CASH!

Bring It On: Fight to the Finish

Design Your Own Vampire Shirt!

Vampire Chic Feeling that creative blood flowing? Enter at Est. Today to make a shirt for you and your friends (starting at only $12!). The winning design will be featured for the world to see at J-14.com!

POLLS

So Freakin' Funny!

On Sale Now

On Sale Now!

TWIST on Twitter!

Video

scenesterHB2.jpg YMI-HOTBUTTON-TWITTER_01.jpg BTG-NINTENDO-BUTTON.jpg tulip.jpg BarbCouponContestHotButton.jpg

See all your chances to win!